Piracy, free books, etc

Posted by on January 26th, 2013

There have been a few arguments, disagreements, debates and falling-outs on Twitter recently around the subject of illegal firesharing. The critic and writer Damien G Walter has been more-or-less at the centre, arguing for the virtues of piracy and free books, aggravating many people both with the content and the tone of his comments. Yesterday, he wrote an article for the Guardian – free to read – that explored the issue a little, although not in depth.

I figured I’d take the opportunity, skimming over some of his comments, to talk a little bit about how I feel about the subject.

All feelings, as always, are subject to change.

1. The Basics

Debates on piracy – and I’ll just use that term as a shorthand for illegal filesharing – tend to be fairly tedious, because the various arguments are familiar and the responses well-worn and rehearsed. It can be a lot like chess openings: the same moves provoke the same replies. For example, if I say “piracy is theft”, you will reply “no, it isn’t!”, and tell me why. Sicilian Dragon.

So let’s get a few basic things out of the way first. Piracy is not simple theft. It isn’t the same as walking out of a shop with a book hidden under your arm. In the latter case, you are depriving the shop of the value of that copy of the book, and – because the shop doesn’t know – possibly depriving future browsers of being able to buy the copy the shop would reorder to take its place. That doesn’t happen with piracy: the original copy remains, and it can still be bought. Theft is subtraction, whereas piracy is multiplication. Piracy, put simply, is getting something for nothing. That is the only real similarity between the two. Although it’s worth noting that the desire to “get something for nothing” is often part of the disdain people have for literal thieves.

Okay, look here:


Walter seems to think that the people who object to piracy lack technological knowledge, which isn’t particularly admirable of him. For what it’s worth, I completely understand that piracy can’t be stopped: that, without gross and wholly unacceptable limitations being placed on personal freedom, or some kind of catastrophic social collapse, it will only ever get easier to copy and distribute files. That’s a world away from claiming, as he has appeared to, that it’s a positive thing. We’ll come back to this.

2. Free books

For the purposes of what follows in this bit, I’m going to conflate piracy with giving books away for free. They’re not the same thing. Clearly, there’s a moral difference between choosing to give your books away yourself and someone else choosing on your behalf. But this is more about the benefits of having free books circulating, so we’ll meld the topics.

A key question put to Walter during the twitter exchanges can be stated as: “if you’re giving books away for free as a marketing strategy, where does the money come from?” It’s a reasonable question. Walter’s response –


- appears to reference Tim O’Reilly’s famous observation that “obscurity is a far greater threat to authors and creative artists than piracy”. Walter also mentions Cory Doctorow -


- who has achieved hundreds of thousands of book sales, even though he gives the same work away for free. Leaving aside the tiresome fact that – once again – Walter assumes his critics are less educated than he is, how does giving stuff away for free to make money work?

Well, it’s fairly straightforward. The act of giving away hundreds of thousands of free books makes no money directly but also costs nothing in itself. The readers who receive those free copies can then be divided into three categories. The largest of these – the vast majority – contains (1) the readers who would never have bought the book anyway and do not go on to support you financially in any way. (This is why a free download absolutely does not equal a lost sale; there was never going to be a sale to these people, so absolutely nothing has been lost). The remaining two categories contain: (2) the people who were not going to buy it but then do support you financially in some way; and (3) the people who would have bought it and then don’t. If (2) is larger than (3), then giving away free books has probably made you money.

It’s essentially a gamble on human nature – but one that can easily pay off, and it shouldn’t be surprising that it does. Most readers, for example, are good people with a passion for books. They want to reward the creators. And it certainly appears to have worked for Cory Doctorow.

Will it work for you? Who knows, but here are some obvious problems I see with the free approach:

a) The world has changed since Doctorow began doing this, which was (correct me if I’m wrong) the early to mid 2000s. His arguments back then included the idea that reading on screens was an unsatisfactory experience, and that many readers who enjoyed the ebook would want a physical copy, either instead of or as well as. And back then, ebooks formed a vanishingly small proportion of the overall market. Given the explosion in ebooks since, and the proliferation of increasingly sophisticated ereading devices, I’m not convinced these points hold true to the same extent.

b) Cory Doctorow is Cory Doctorow. Not only is he a bestselling writer of fiction, he’s an articulate and sought-after expert on digital media, DRM, copyright etc. His public persona, in other words, is inextricably linked with this subject matter; his reputation has been built on it. Yes, every success story can be considered a special case, but Doctorow is perceived not simply as a writer who gives his work away for free, but as a pioneer in the whole area of digital rights. You will not be a pioneer; he got there first. You will just be someone giving your work away for free. And the more people pursue the free strategy (much as with the 99p pricing strategy) the harder it will be to stand out.

c) We’re not in the music industry, where artists can at least hope to make money from won-over fans who maybe don’t pay for the music itself but at least attend tours and buy merchandise. (Writers can perform, of course, but – again – you’re not Cory Doctorow. Pub bands on their debuts get larger crowds than many midlist authors). We’re also different in that our media is produced and consumed in different ways. There are fewer readers than listeners, it takes much longer to read a novel than to listen to an album, and the replay factor is considerably lower. Those three factors combined make giving a novel away for free significantly more of a financial risk than giving away an album.

3. What this means for you.

Doctorow is certainly more aware than Walter appears to be that his approach won’t work for everyone. Walter seems to think:


It would take a lifetime to unpack everything wrong with such a blanket statement. He also appears to take the position that because the most pirated authors are the most successful, the former causes the latter:


It’s possible, in certain cases, that this is true, but I’d suggest that for the most part he’s getting the cart a huge distance before the horse there. I have more faith in another of O’Reilly’s famous observations as an explanation: that piracy is a form of progressive taxation. The most successful authors are pirated the most because they’re the most successful authors, so they pay the most “tax”. At best, it seems baseless to assume most of them became successful because of piracy. Evidence, basically, or GTFO.

4. Where you are determines what you see

There will always be a degree of subjectivity to this debate. Much has been made of Walter’s position as a largely unpublished writer. I think that’s unfair, although it’s true that the loudest exponents of piracy and free books are generally likely to be the people least at risk from it – the very successful who can weather it, like Doctorow and Neil Gaiman, and the people with nothing to lose from it. People like me, somewhere on the midlist, are more conflicted. This is human nature. But I dislike this kind of thinking:



Because, yes, obviously I’m concerned about my own position – but why imagine that everybody is purely out for themselves? The larger debate, which encompasses piracy, free books, cheap books, ebooks, and so on, is also about the kind of society you want to live in, along with the approach you want society to have to culture.

At this point in my life, for example, voting Tory would probably benefit me economically, but I would never do so, because I don’t think my actions, and the repercussions of them, should be centred solely on what’s best for me. So when it comes to ebooks and piracy, I’m not just thinking about my sales; I’m also thinking about the large number of people who have helped me get my books where they are, and the whole social and financial infrastructure that underlies that. I’m thinking, for example, about what the high street looks like. I’m thinking about sustainability. I’m thinking about where people are going to work to earn the money to buy the things people are selling at these cheap prices, and where they’re going to work to be able to afford to produce them. I’m thinking about whether what comes after is really what is better simply because it comes after. In short, it’s really not just about what leaves me with the most money. And that, incidentally, is also why I buy the media I want and like.

5. What I think

I have endless and fantastically violent contempt for the sites making money off the back of work they didn’t help create, and for the people behind them. I have nothing, really, against the ordinary people who illegally download my books – I can’t stop you, most of you wouldn’t have bought them anyway, and I just hope that, if you enjoy them, you consider buying some of them at some point, to support not just me, but also the other people, less visible, whose work made my books possible in the first place.

One last thing:


I think this is a good article to end with a link to. It’s lengthy, but very good. Along with other points, it makes the case that free isn’t really free. I suppose it emphasises the points I just made, especially directly above, and that last tweet of Damien’s. Here’s a snippet:

“Let’s look at other things you (or your parents) might pay for each month and compare.

Smart phone with data plan: $40-100 a month.

High speed internet access: $30-60 dollars a month. Wait, but you use the university network? Well, buried in your student fees or tuition you are being charged a fee on the upper end of that scale.

Tuition at American University, Washington DC (excluding fees, room and board and books): $2,086 a month.

Car insurance or Metro card?  $100 a month?

Or simply look at the  value of the web appliances you use to enjoy music:

$2,139.50 = 1 smart phone + 1 full size ipod + 1 macbook.

Why do you pay real money for this other stuff but not music?


The existential questions that your generation gets to answer are these:

Why do we value the network and hardware that delivers music but not the music itself?

Why are we willing to pay for computers, iPods, smartphones, data plans, and high speed internet access but not the music itself?

Why do we gladly give our money to some of the largest richest corporations in the world but not the companies and individuals who create and sell music?

This is a bit of hyperbole to emphasize the point. But it’s as if:

Networks: Giant mega corporations. Cool! have some money!

Hardware: Giant mega corporations. Cool! have some money!

Artists: 99.9 % lower middle class. Screw you, you greedy bastards!

Congratulations, your generation is the first generation in history to rebel by unsticking it to the man and instead sticking it to the weirdo freak musicians!

I am genuinely stunned by this. Since you appear to love first generation Indie Rock, and as a founding member of a first generation Indie Rock band I am now legally obligated to issue this order: kids, lawn, vacate.

You are doing it wrong.”

This entry was posted on Saturday, January 26th, 2013 at 11:23 pm and is filed under Damien Walter, General, Piracy, Rant. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.


59 Responses to “Piracy, free books, etc”

  1. Attention ‘artisan authors’: digital self-publishing is harder than it looks « WORLDPC.US Says:

    [...] his webpage, the Left Room, Steve Mosby argues that Doctorow’s status as a pioneer in the field means there is no way [...]

  2. D Says:

    “Good writers do well… bad writers don’t.”

    Yes, because writers who don’t “monetize” (ugh, I hate that word) their work by doing personal appearances are clearly inferior to those who go on long book tours and speaking engagements that have little to do with their actual work. Doctorow’s rather turgid prose is clearly better than Thomas Pynchon, who doesn’t even bother to have an author photo, the creep!

    God, the ignorance of Walters’ statement makes me rage.

  3. Mark Charan Newton » On Pirates Says:

    [...] the same subject, Steve Mosby linked to this powerful piece on music downloads, which I think deserves even wider coverage, particularly [...]

  4. Paulette Says:

    Hi, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog site in Opera, it looks fine but when opening
    in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick
    heads up! Other then that, amazing blog!

  5. Judi Says:

    This website was… how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I’ve
    found something that helped me. Cheers!

  6. Brenton Says:

    It includes traditional paintings, photographs, and sculptures.
    He might not know alternative routes to get you
    to the airport as fast as possible or he might not have a good driving history.
    Additionally, you can agree to include some important details as the color of the car or the type of
    decorations they will provide.

  7. Boom Beach Hack Says:

    I appreciate, lead to I discovered just what I was taking a look for.
    You have ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day.

    My web site – Boom Beach Hack

  8. Yes Wellness Promo Code Says:

    What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this web site daily, this site is in fact pleasant and the people are truly sharing pleasant thoughts.

  9. kaapo kaarina Says:

    Little angels in gas mask visiting the earth or showing earth a tap with dark dirty water
    and a skeleton drinking it. ‘Steven Universe’, created by Rebecca Sugar,
    will follow the adventures of the Crystal Gems, a group of heroes made up of three superpowered ladies
    and a less-than-super boy named Steven. And when these animals interact with people alongside really green scenery, it makes for the cartoon songs to be really soulful.

  10. Testosterone Boost Review Says:

    Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the images on this blog
    loading? I’m trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

  11. racialpersonnel73.webs.com Says:

    It’s really a cool and useful piece of information. I’m satisfied that you simply shared this useful
    info with us. Pleasse keep us up to date like
    this. Thank you for sharing.

    my page – diet tips (racialpersonnel73.webs.com)

  12. beras merah Says:

    Hey there, You have done an excellent job.

    I will definitely digg it and personally suggest to my
    friends. I’m sure they will be benefited from this web site.

  13. plus.google.com Says:

    We’re a bunch of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
    Your web site provided us with valuable info to work
    on. You’ve done a formidable process and
    our whole group will probably be grateful to you.

  14. nitro x Review Says:

    nitro x Review

    the left room» Blog Archive » Piracy, free books, etc

  15. books and info Says:

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on body odor question. Regards

  16. NO2 Surge Reviews Says:

    Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed!

    Very helpful info specially the final section :) I care for such
    info a lot. I was seeking this certain information for a long time.
    Thanks and best of luck.

  17. sbobet promotion Says:

    I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.

    I will bookmark your blog and check again here regularly.
    I am quite sure I’ll learn many new stuff right here!
    Good luck for the next!

  18. Heart attack defender Reviews Says:

    Heart attack defender Reviews

    the left room» Blog Archive » Piracy, free books, etc

  19. Revolutionary Colon Cleanse Says:

    Hurrah, that’s what I was looking for, what a material! present here at
    this weblog, thanks admin of this web page.

  20. youtu.be Says:

    I read this post completely on the topic of the comparison of latest
    and previous technologies, it’s remarkable article.

  21. Celluria Says:

    Pretty component of content. I simply stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert
    that I get in fact loved account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I fulfillment you access consistently

  22. broadband Says:

    The apps are unique in the manner they are designed for
    i – Pad. If an organization hires a service
    provider for its IT functions rather than doing them itself, it is regarded as
    IT outsourcing. According to the 2011 Global Services Location Index (GSLI) of AT
    Kearney, India, China and Malaysia are the top three outsourcing destinations in Asia at the moment, but India
    has maintained its lead consistently.

  23. Taren Says:

    You are so interesting! I don’t believe I’ve read through a single thing like that before.
    So nice to discover someone with a few original thoughts on this topic.
    Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This site is something that’s needed on the internet,
    someone with a bit of originality!

  24. Spencer Lodge Says:

    In appointing a Personal Chief Monetary Officer (Private CFO), your
    monetary management is outsourced to Candor Financial Administration.

  25. Juvamend Reviews Says:

    Juvamend Reviews

    the left room» Blog Archive » Piracy, free books, etc

  26. Der Pou Cheat Says:

    Simultaneously, this is one the oldest of the b st fps games
    ver gaming made. Mr Prashant Reddy, game art and interactive courses in the
    Norrn Searching Party.

  27. cs 1.6 download Says:

    A game server for your computer upgrade. Please reference the
    time, otherwise, it’s faster, if something goes wrong we have a favorite game to kill our spare time and to richen our life.
    Social gamers who want to buy LOL Korean AccountIf you don’t have US game servers IP address for Elsword US server.

    There are expensive game servers and have never managed to have a co-leader.

    A game server to pay for the clan relies on you
    since you are the popular pastimes for various individuals.

  28. Natural Heal for Kidney Says:

    Piece of writing writing is also a excitement, if you be acquainted
    with after that you can write if not it is complicated to

  29. ios games like pokemon Says:

    My family always say that I am killing my time here at net, but I know I am getting familiarity every day by reading such good articles or reviews.

  30. hivoverfifty.com Says:

    They are a very good way to promote business service.

    However Yahoo marketing and other pay per click
    search engines offer some excellent traffic at a more reasonable
    price. Make certain that the payment gateway you are making use of, permits similar languages as the remaining of the web pages so that they can match well together.

  31. Celina Says:

    And bby high grade quality education, it often. Sheds light on that.
    Children maay be less structurally sound than abc cribs with four
    minutes. In particular, it’s even better for herr
    and told us we should pay close attention to meticulous detail were really cheap at the abc Monkey Puzzlle exercises utmost attention towards the store, or even increasing.
    One of the experiences that children with depression. The mattress is
    designed to resemble that at the back of the reasons that continually changing the way.

  32. wiko cink slim blanc Says:

    Now that your furniture has arrived, you will need to make sure that you
    are satisfied with your purchase. With all of the materials and styles available, there
    is reason behind your bar not to match your furnishings.

    Study the peace of mind and come policies and tips.

  33. Cleta Says:

    “Marriage is popular because it combines the maximum
    of temptation with the maximum of opportunity. IN tthis ceremony, Haldi paste, specially made by the brides mother, is brought
    in a silver bkwl that is applied on the groom. Yoou shluld note that bustles are required in dresses with long
    trains; therefore, if you aree planning of having
    attire with a long train, you should consider the type of bustle that you want.

  34. fashion inspiration Says:

    excellent submit, very informative. I wonder why the
    other specialists of this sector do not notice this.
    You should proceed your writing. I’m confident,
    you’ve a huge readers’ base already!

  35. Wilhemina Says:

    Hello to every one, the contents present at this web site
    are in fact awesome for people experience, well, keep up the nice
    work fellows.

  36. Leslee Says:

    Frozen cow dung was used as a hockey puck in the olden days,
    after which the upgraded version involved using sliced-up lacrosse balls.
    Article Source: how you can win back her heart
    to where she belongs by your side. There are thousands of potential side effects that are not being
    looked at because we don’t have a deep enough understanding of the system.

  37. peindre un sol Says:

    Furniture plays a very important role in making our bedroom a perfect bedroom.
    Working without one will save you a great deal of time and money.
    One of the best pieces of outdoor wood furniture is, without doubt,
    the built in braai.

  38. kitchenaid food processor Says:

    The antioxidant effects of juices also help the body to detoxify and remove the toxins, fats, preservatives and chemicals that diets of processed foods leave behind in your
    body. Better yet, homemade baby food is better than store bought ones.
    Food processors feature providers for its functionality
    of shredding, chopping, slicing, grating
    and mixing solid foods unevenly.

  39. Quotes app Says:

    My brother recommended I would possibly like this blog.
    He was totally right. This post actually made my day.
    You cann’t consider simply how so much time I had spent for this info!
    Thank you!

    my site Quotes app

  40. facebook.twitter Says:

    Hi colleagues, how is everything, and what you would like to say concerning this
    post, in my view its truly amazing designed for me.

  41. bluetooth receiver Says:

    constantly i used to read smaller content that also clear
    their motive, and that is also happening with this paragraph which I am reading now.

    My blogging site about technological know-how:
    bluetooth receiver

  42. Ray Ban ZX300 Says:

    I’m amazed, I have to admit. Seldom do I encounter a blog
    that’s both equally educative and entertaining, and without a doubt, you’ve hit the nail on the head.
    The problem is something too few folks are speaking intelligently
    about. I am very happy I came across this in my search for something relating
    to this.

  43. easy apple crumble recipes Says:

    continuously i used to read smaller articles that also clear their
    motive, and that is also happening with this piece of writing
    which I am reading here.

  44. Kim Kardashian Hollywood Money Says:

    99) – The game description is quite confusing, but it seems to be a puzzle game
    where you try to get the bumper boats to their like-colored
    buoys and need to use all of the boats to bounce a boat to the buoy.
    Most recently, reports have surfaced that Khloe Kardashian’s husband, Lamar Odom, is being demoted
    to the NBA’s Developmental League. British royals wanted to stop the presses
    on the pics.

  45. www.thelearningnetwork.asia Says:

    The new activation system, called Volume Activation (VA) requires the use
    of a special Multiple Activation Key (MAK) or a
    Key Management Server (KMS). I was just reading your article about magnet polarity.
    No matter the reason, in Office 2010, changing the product key is simple.

  46. ??????? 2014 ????? Says:

    Piece of writing writing is also a fun, if you be acquainted with after
    that you can write otherwise it is difficult to write.

  47. Hong Says:

    Kim Vo salon in Beverly Hills Montage Hotel on Cannon 1 block North of Wilshire offers a fantastic hair gloss treatment that
    returns shine and a healthy glow to lack luster locks.
    Hair loss in women is generally very gradual, with the rate accelerating during pregnancy and at menopause.
    The usual recommended dosage of gotu kola is 600
    mg three times a day.

  48. Indian recipes Says:

    Thanks for every other informative website. Where else may just I get that type of information written in such an ideal method?
    I’ve a challenge that I’m simply now operating on, and I have
    been on the glance out for such info.

  49. Productos Para Zapatos Says:

    Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have
    truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    In any case I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  50. harga kasur busa latex murah Says:

    Great article. I will be experiencing some of these
    issues as well..

  51. http://offgrid.removingmoldtop.com Says:

    Solar electricity will probably be utilized in an electrolysis process that separates the hydrogen and oxygen in water so the hydrogen can be utilized in gasoline cells for transportation and in buildings.

  52. smoke Says:

    Smoking affects the potency levels in men and many times it has been noted that smokers are generally impotent.

    com, a leading service provider for fire and water damage cleanups.

    All these years I have constantly maintained which patients need to be told the truth or offered with enough and impartial info to
    enable those todecide for themselves.

  53. Shoot the Apple 2 free Says:

    Gamefly offers quick shipment where in you will either acquire or return a
    game within Shoot the Apple 2 free-4days.
    It really is offered with an alternative
    to connect with various social networks like Facebook, Twitter
    and MySpace.

  54. annonces football Says:

    An item of furniture that has cost a fraction of the cost of more pricey items is likely to have a much shorter lifespan. These are
    designed for those long afternoons relaxing outdoors.
    The garden can become the heart of the property as well as the area
    which is great for celebrations and get togethers.

  55. filmmaking Says:

    I’m not sure where you are getting your information, however good topic.

    I needs to spend some time finding out much more or understanding more.

    Thank you for great info I was searching for this information for my mission.

  56. Jonah Says:

    Thanks for the marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed reading it, you might be a great author.

    I will ensure that I bookmark your blog and will eventually come
    back sometime soon. I want to encourage you continue your great work,
    have a nice evening!

  57. Karbonn Sparkle V back covers india Says:

    Thanks for a marvelous posting! I certainly enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author.I
    will be sure to bookmark your blog and definitely will come back in the foreseeable future.
    I want to encourage one to continue your great posts, have a nice evening!

  58. Deena Says:

    Hello, i feel that i noticed you visited my weblog thus i got here to return the favor?.I’m trying
    to find things to improve my site!I guess its good enough to use some of your ideas!!

  59. fifa 14 hack coins and points generator Says:

    each time i used to read smaller articles which also clear their motive, and that
    is also happening with this article which I am reading here.

Leave a Reply